Anastasia Tinted Brow Gel vs Dipbrow Gel: Which Brow Gel is Best?

I'm a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.

If you want your eyebrows to look on point, then look no further than Anastasia Beverly Hills. They have lots of brow gels and pomades that can get you that full, defined appearance you crave, but today we’re going to compare two iconic products. We’re putting Anastasia Tinted Brow Gel vs Dipbrow Gel to see which is best.

While they share some similarities, there are some key differences you need to know about.

Read on to see which Anastasia eyebrow gel is right for you.

Anastasia Tinted Brow GelAnastasia Dipbrow Gel


When it comes to Anastasia Tinted Brow Gel vs Dipbrow Gel, both give you fuller, more defined brows. However, the way they go about it is completely different.

Anastasia Tinted Brow Gel uses highly reflective pearls that add some shimmer and shine to your brows. This subtle reflection brings more attention to your face while also highlighting the color of your brows. You’ll find this also adds dimension and fullness to your brows while also covering any gray.

While it reflects more when wet, it dries down to a matte finish that looks completely natural and beautiful.

Anastasia Dipbrow Gel is similar to the Anastasia Dipbrow Pomade, but it’s a little creamier and easier to work with. This highly-saturated formula adds to your eyebrow dimensions while also boosting volume and fullness. It looks more natural and matte than the Tinted Brow Gel, but it also lacks the slight reflective properties.

It’s hard to determine which is better here with Anastasia Dipbrow Gel vs Tinted Brow Gel since they both serve different purposes. If you want your brows to really pop with some extra color, then Tinted Brow Gel is better. If you want thicker, more defined brows, then consider Dipbrow Gel.

Check Price: Anastasia Tinted Brow Gel – >


The feel of makeup is almost as important as the look. You don’t want something too thin or clumpy. You also don’t want makeup that’s difficult to apply. We’re going to talk about how both of these eyebrow gels feel both from the bottle and after they dry.

Starting off with Tinted Brow Gel, this is around medium thickness and applies easily to your brows. It comes out of the tube clean, clings to your eyebrows, and hits that golden spot of not too thick, not too thin.

The gel dries down matte and feels natural against your touch. While you obviously shouldn’t touch it too much (you don’t want it to come off), you won’t even feel it there as you go about your day. This makes it ideal for all-day wear.

Next up is Dip Brow Gel. Many people compare this to the Dipbrow Pomade because it’s a very similar product. The only major differences are that it uses a teardrop shaped applicator and comes in a tube. Another big difference is that Anastasia Beverly Hills made this a little thinner than the pomade so that it’s easier to apply.

That being said, it’s still somewhat thicker than the Tinted Brow Gel. It’s also creamier and feels a little better when you’re putting it on, but you do have to work it somewhat more. Not only that, but it’s a waterproof formula.

It has a similar feel when dried. You’ll find this dries down matte and doesn’t easily rub off. It won’t get in your way as you go about your daily activities.

One word of caution though. Some people have had problems with Dipbrow Gel and write it off for being clumpy. That isn’t an issue if you use it correctly. This needs a lighter touch than you might be used to. Start with a little and work from there. You shouldn’t have any problems then.

Both are around a medium thickness. Tinted Brow Gel is the thinner of the two and somewhat easier to apply, but Dipbrow gel has a thicker, creamier feel that’s also quite nice. They are both similar when they dry.

Check Price: Anastasia Dipbrow Gel – >


From lipstick to eyeshadow, you always want to make sure you get the best color possible. It’s even more important with eyebrow gel because you need it to match your natural color.

Tinted Brow Gel offers seven different shades. Most are warm, but there are cool tones as well and you can choose from popular colors like auburn, brunette, espresso, and caramel. You should have no problem finding the right color for your eyebrows.

Not to be outdone, Dipbrow Gel comes in 11 different shades. You’ll find many of the same shades as with Tinted Brow Gel, but there are some additional ones like medium brown and soft brown. This makes it just a tad easier to get the right color for your brows.

The color choice is similar, but there is one other thing we should note. Tinted Brow Gel is somewhat lighter overall. Plus, if you remember from before, it’s also more reflective due to the pearls in the formula.

On the other hand, Dipbrow Gel tends to be darker and is more saturated. This is better for those who want deeper coverage or dark colors.

Overall, we like Dipbrow Gel somewhat better, but both are great depending on your preference.

How Long Do They Last?

The last thing you need is to stop what you’re doing during your busy day and reapplying your brows. No one has time for that. So, how long do both of these eyebrow gels last?

While your experience might be somewhat different depending on how you apply it and how your body interacts with the gel, most Anastasia Tinted Brow Gel reviews and Anastasia Dipbrow Gel reviews mention that the gel lasts all day. You should have no problem making it morning to night without worrying about your eyebrows.

There’s really no difference between the two here, so they’re equal. We will say that those who found the Dipbrow Gel clumpy (those who put on too much, as we said above) found that it didn’t last all day, but you won’t have this problem if you apply it correctly.

What’s the Difference Between Anastasia Tinted Brow Gel vs Dipbrow Gel?

You may have noticed that so far the differences have been slight and based on preference. The truth is that these products are both great and similar in many ways. They both help your eyebrows look amazing, have similar applicators, and even have many of the same shades.

So, what’s the difference between Tinted Brow Gel and Dipbrow Gel?

Well, thickness is the first thing you might notice. When it comes to Anastasia Dipbrow Gel vs Tinted Brow Gel, you’ll notice that Dipbrow is thicker and creamier while Tinted Brow Gel is somewhat thinner and easier to apply.

There’s also the color. While they share many of the same shades, Tinted Brow Gel is more reflective and a little lighter while Dipbrow Gel is darker and more saturated.

The same could be said for the look. Tinted Brow Gel reflects more light and brings more attention to your brows. However, the more saturated Dipbrow Gel does a better job of covering gray hairs.

Anastasia Tinted Brow GelAnastasia Dipbrow Gel

Final Thoughts

So, which one is better when it comes to Anastasia Tinted Brow Gel vs Dipbrow Gel? Tinted Brow Gel is better for those who want a somewhat thinner, reflective, bright eyebrow makeup. Dipbrow Gel is more saturated, thicker, and similar to a pomade but easier to apply.

Which do you choose? Let us know.

Leave a Comment