Mario Badescu vs Thayers (Best Face Toner Mist)

I'm a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.

If you’re looking for the best face toner, then we found two of the top products for you. For those who don’t know, face toner revitalizes your skin without stripping out oils. While astringents often look similar, toner hydrates and improves your skin without being too harsh. Our Mario Badescu vs Thayers review will show you which of these is right for you

Our Thayers vs Mario Badescu review is going to focus on uses, effectiveness, feeling, and then any other differences we can find. You’ll know which is the right face toner for revitalizing your skin.

Read on and discover which is right for you.

Mario Badescu TonerThayers Witch Hazel Toner

Specific Products

Both of these brands make a variety of products, so we wanted to make sure you knew exactly what we were looking at during our review.

We are comparing Mario Badescu Facial Spray with Aloe, Herbs and Rosewater vs Thayers Alcohol-Free Witch Hazel Facial Mist Toner with Aloe Vera.

Both of these work on all skin types, and they are known for being gentle and rejuvenating to your face. Simply spray the face toner mist on your face, neck, or even your hair, and feel how it works to calm irritation while making you look and feel your best.

Thayers uses a traditional recipe that includes witch hazel while Mario Badescu uses iconic calming ingredients such as aloe and rosewater.


These are two very similar face mist toners that have nearly identical uses. As such, we have to call this a tie.

The first thing we noticed, and absolutely loved, was that these are on-the-go, convenient facial mists that you can carry in your bag with ease. Spray your face, neck, or any other area when you need a pick-me-up or if you feel that your face is irritated. The spray top ensures you can easily get a quick misting in seconds.

We found in our Mario Badescu vs Thayers review that Mario’s label says it works on your face, neck, and hair while Thayers only mentions facial use. At the same time, many people online report using both products on the entire body without problems. As such, we can’t say that one has more uses than another.

So, when should you use a face toner?

Many people use this morning and night after washing their face. This goes on before any moisturizers or serums. At the same time, you can use these whenever you feel you need a little extra hydration or revitalization. All it takes is a quick spray to feel better.

Check Price: Mario Badescu Toner ->

Thayers vs Mario Badescu: Effectiveness

If you are looking for the most popular face mist on Amazon, then both of these fit the bill. Mario Badescu Rosewater is the top Amazon face toner while Thayers is currently the fourth most popular in this category. Does that mean that Mario Badescu is more effective?

The Mario Badescu facial spray combines rose canina seed extract to rejuvenate your skin, thyme extract to clarify, and seaweed extract to soften and hydrate your skin. You also get aloe and other timeless ingredients to make this the most effective face toner we’ve seen in a long time.

Thayers Witch Hazel Toner is an alcohol-free face toner that also combines many of the best ingredients you can imagine, and it’s mostly organic as well. This also includes aloe vera along with rose water. The major difference here is witch hazel.

Witch hazel toner benefits include tightening pores and reducing inflammation so your skin looks and feels healthier. It also provides antioxidants while regulating oil production.

In general we would say that Mario Badescu facial mist is more effective, but it’s nearly a tie. We think you’d be happy with either, but Mario Badescu wins by being slightly more versatile, and we love the dewy finish it leaves on the skin.

Check Price: Thayers Witch Hazel Toner ->

Mario Badescu vs Thayers: Feeling

The reason anyone uses face toner, aside from improving your skin’s health, is that it feels good. The best toners for your face will leave you feeling fresh and like you can take on the world. So, which of these toners feels better on your face?

As toner mists, both of them are light and refreshing. You’d feel great after using either of them, but the competition is stiff, so we can’t just say it’s a tie.

Thayers toner leaves you feeling cool, hydrated, and moisturized. It quickly absorbs and reduces irritation and inflammation. You’ll feel like you walked through a summer rain and it’s amazing.

Mario Badescu is similar, but the important difference is that it leaves a soft, dewy texture that’s truly wonderful. We suggest trying this at least once to see what this is like. Many people love the soft finish that this mist leaves, and we found that it’s a big selling point for many people.

While both are amazing, we have to say that the face toner from Mario Badescu is better.

Check Price: Mario Badescu Toner ->

Which is Better, Mario Badescu or Thayers?

This is a hard one. Both of these are very similar, from their rose-scented aromas to their gentle, revitalizing feel. They also have a great spray top that ensures you can tone your face on the go.

In general, we think Mario Badescu is a little better. It smells a little better (though those who prefer mild scents might prefer Thayers), leaves a better finish, and is somewhat more effective.

However, Thayers is mostly organic and many people love witch hazel for its numerous skin boosting benefits.

It’s nearly a tie, but we like Mario toner just a little bit better.

Check Price: Thayers Witch Hazel Toner ->

What is the Difference Between Mario Badescu and Thayers?

Curious about what is the difference between Thayers and Mario Badescu? We found that these toners are very similar, but there were some differences we could identify.

By the way, check out these other Mario Badescu reviews for more information:

Their ingredients are similar, but Mario Badescu includes a few more extracts and ingredients that leave you feeling fresh and revitalized. At the same time, Thayers includes witch hazel, which is a coveted face toner ingredient because it has many natural benefits.

The scent is also amazing for both. While they both have a rose-scented aroma, we liked that Mario Badescu toner’s smell was stronger, but not overpowering. Thayers was mild by comparison. That being said, this depends on your preference.

Mario also leaves a dewy finish that many people love, and we have to agree.

Mario Badescu TonerThayers Witch Hazel Toner

Final Thoughts

So, who wins here with Mario Badescu Facial Spray with Aloe, Herbs and Rosewater vs Thayers Alcohol-Free Witch Hazel Facial Mist Toner with Aloe Vera? Both of these are amazing, but we liked Mario just a little bit more. It felt better, smelled better, and was a little more effective. They’re very close, but we have to agree that this is the number one toner on Amazon.

1 thought on “Mario Badescu vs Thayers (Best Face Toner Mist)”

Leave a Comment