I'm a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
With so many eyeliners out there it’s hard to choose the right one for yourself. Simply looking at pencil eyeliners isn’t enough. They might look nearly identical, but things can be very different once you take off the cap. Today we’re comparing Stila vs Benefit eyeliner to see which is superior. Specifically we’re going to compare Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner vs Benefit Roller Liner Black True Matte Liquid Eyeliner.
Which one is best? We’re going to compare Benefit vs Stila eyeliner based on feel, application, color, whether they’re waterproof, and any other differences we can find. By the end of this you’ll know exactly which one is right for you.
Stila vs Benefit: Feel
There are some awful eyeliners out there, you may have used them in the past. They’re the really cheap ones that feel clumpy and disgusting on your eyes. Plus, they love to run with the slightest bit of water, or they slowly get into your eyes as your blinking. Absolutely not fun, and not what we’d ever recommend.
With that said, how do these eyeliners feel? You want something that goes on smooth, have an even coat, and doesn’t irritate your eyes even if it’s hours after you put it on.
We have to say that both are good, but we think Stila All Day Eye Liner felt better. It was smoother, was easier to put on, and we barely felt it there. Honestly, it’s a natural fit and it felt great.
Benefit Liner Roller Eyeliner felt good as well. It was smooth and didn’t cause any irritation, so we can recommend it. However, it seemed to be lacking something when compared to Stila. It just didn’t feel quite as good, like it was a little heavier and more apparent. We’d call this good while Stila was great.
Both feel good and either can be worn for hours, but we preferred Stila because it felt more natural.
Benefit vs Stila: Application
Liquid eyeliner should be easy to apply. That’s especially true with these pencil eyeliners that have precision tips. You should have no problem going around your eye line and applying the makeup as needed. However, you might know by now that some liquid eyeliner pencils aren’t that simple.
Just as we discussed in the above section, sometimes the makeup is clumpy and doesn’t feel even. It might also not apply correctly, or you might have to cover your eye line multiple times before you have enough for your aesthetic.
Ideally the eyeliner should by saturated, should only require a few passes at most, and it should apply simply and easily. Plus, with the precision tip, you should be able to apply it exactly where you want it without there being any issues.
Both of these fit that ideal. They are top brands after all, so we’re not surprised that they are both easy to use. Just remove the cap, go around your eyes, and you’re all finished. Nothing could be easier.
Much like how Stila felt better, we found that it applied better as well. We had to do fewer passes and it felt a little easier as well. Benefit eyeliner was simple enough and a great runner-up, but we think Stila was just a tiny bit better.
In the other sections we said that the two were close, but Stila was a tiny bit better. This section is going to be different. There’s a huge disparity in the number of colors offered as you’ll soon see with our Stila vs Benefit eyeliner review. Benefit does a great job with its colors, but Stila blows it away.
Let’s take a look at Benefit first. This comes in two colors:
- Benefit Roller Liner Black True Matte Liquid Eyeliner
- Benefit Roller Liner Brown True Matte Liquid Eyeliner
As we just said, Benefit eyeliner colors are beautiful and they are highly pigmented, but it’s only two. Stila offers nine colors along with three tips. You can choose from:
- Stila All Day Alloy
- Stila All Day Rich Chocolate
- Stila All Day Intense Black
- Stila All Day Intense Jade
- Stila All Day Intense Labradorite
- Stila All Day Intense Smoky Quartz
- Stila All Day Midnight
- Stila All Day Paradise Pink
- Stila All Day White
That’s a lot of options!
One thing we can say about Benefit is that the colors are a little more matte than Stila, which some of you might prefer. That aside, Stila is the clear winner here. You get way more options, and the colors look better in our opinion.
Many people prefer waterproof eyeliner and it makes sense. It’s right on your eyes, so you don’t want your natural tears to make the makeup streak or prematurely fade. Plus, waterproof makeup lasts much longer overall and won’t come off in the rain.
So, you might be wondering if either or both of these are waterproof. Our Benefit Roller Liner Black True Matte Liquid Eyeliner review found that the Benefit eyeliner is waterproof. Our Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner review came to the same result. Both of these are waterproof.
They are also waterproof to the same degree, so it’s a tie between them. There’s no difference here in our Stila eyeliner vs Benefit eyeliner comparison.
If you were looking for a non-waterproof eyeliner (they are easier to remove when the day is over), then read our KVD Tattoo Eyeliner review to see how it compares against Stila.
What’s the Difference Between Stila and Benefit Eyeliner?
Curious about the difference between Benefit and Stila eyeliner? In many ways they are very similar. Both of them are pencil liquid eyeliners. This means they are easy to carry around, store, and use. Plus, they have very precise tips so that you can easily place the eyeliner exactly where you need it.
We also compared Stila to other great eyeliners, read more about them here:
While they were very similar in feel and application, we found that Stila was just a little better. It’s hard to explain, but it felt better and went on easier. You’ll just have to try for yourself to see what we’re talking about!
However, one area that isn’t subjective is color. Benefit only offers a few colors while Stila Liquid Eyeliner All Day Waterproof has nine colors. If you only want black or brown, then we can debate about which is better. If you want green, pink, white, or another fun color, then Stila is your only option!
While there aren’t a tremendous number of differences, we give the overall win to Stila.
So, who wins in the battle between Stila Stay All Day vs Benefit Roller Liner? It’s close in many areas. They are very similar when it comes to waterproofing, feel, and application. The one area where Stila easily wins is color, and that’s really our deciding factor here.
Both are great and we see why many people might like Benefit, but we give the win to Stila. If you haven’t tried it yet, then we suggest getting some and seeing how it feels. You’re sure to love it.